James Durbin Leaving American Idol?
Okay – did you really think that headline was serious? Were you scared?
Of course, James Durbin is NOT leaving American Idol – I’m predicting he’s likely to be the overall winner!
Did your favorite American Idol contestant get voted off this week?
With 30 million votes in one night – unless a contestant connects with America – they will be sent packing with tears and shattered dreams in the most dramatic rose ceremony ever! … oh sorry… wrong show.
Your eliminated contestant is…. to be announced in a minute…
But truly sad and scary news – Casey Abrams is in the hospital – no announcement about what he’s suffering with but we all hope he gets better soon and back to the competition. The show would not be the same without Casey!
American Idol results show began with a Michael Jackson medley – it was actually quite telling and a good indicator of who is ready to move forward in their career and who is a fledgling artist. As the show has continued it seems that America may want a refined and polished artist as their Idol, rather than a newbie who has to learn the ropes. The opening act made Pia Toscano look amazing, Naima Adedapo stand out, James Durbin front and center – and yet others faded, obviously lip syncing or not singing well and then it became a lip syncing fest again – I hate it when they do that!
Adam Lambert returns to American Idol – I have compared James Durbin with Adam Lambert in the past – but watching Adam perform tonight – I can honestly say I think James is WAY more talented and I like him so much more. There’s no comparison from here on out. (Okay – for all you Adam Lambert fans out there – please no hate mail – we’re all entitled to opinions and just because I’m right doesn’t mean you have to spread any ugliness… insert big cheeky grin here.)
Back to our results… the bottom three this week were Karen Rodriguez, Ashthon Jones, Haley Reinhart.
It’s a bit telling that all 3 in the bottom were girls – they need to step it up this season in order to compete with the guys.
The eliminated contestant was Ashthon Jones. When Jennifer Lopez had to tell her that the judges would not be saving her for the season, I have to say that it was a bit touching – you could tell that it was hard on Jennifer to disappoint Ashthon. It’s not that Ashthon is not talented – she is – but I think emotional connection to the audience and to the music goes much farther in today’s society of social media and personal connection.
Wishing Ashthon good luck, hoping Casey gets better soon, and excited to see what next week brings!
Related articles
- “James Durbin American Idol “Maybe I’m Amazed†(Video) Top 13 Paul McCartney” and related posts (tv.popcrunch.com)
- Adam Lambert Returns To Idol (khmx.radio.com)
- ‘American Idol’ Top 13 Talk About Their Fan Nicknames (mtv.com)
- Maybe We’re Amazed by James Durbin… (thehollywoodgossip.com)


March 29th, 2011 at 12:46 am
All I can say is that you obviously haven’t heard Adam sing much and you are comparing just a few performances of James with heavy help from producers while Adam kicked a** all Season 8 doing mostly everything on his own? Compare Adam’s A Change Is Gonna Come to James’s and tell me you think James is better. You must be deaf if you think that screeching was better than Adam’s version. Adam can sing any genre and do it well and that is why people like Slash, Meatloaf, Queen, Smokey Robinson, etc. are going nuts for him and that is why he got a Grammy nomination. Opera singers are blown away by him. You have obviously never heard Adam sing live or heard his YouTubes prior to Idol. Just YouTube “Adam Lambert Brigadoon” and tell me he can’t sing. Music critics are saying James isn’t even in Adam’s league. James is severely overrated and I have read that on many blogs. DDD Music Forums aren’t impressed with James and didn’t even make a thread on him while they did with Adam and they’ve ranked Adam as #2 Most Technically Skilled Rock Vocalist in the world. Let’s see James do a sold out world tour and get a Grammy nomination off his debut album.
March 29th, 2011 at 1:46 am
Now… please be nice. I’ve admitted that Adam is incredibly talented. He’s just a bit too over the top for my taste. I am cheering for James because I like him – both as a person – and his ability. Obviously he will improve even more over time – Adam has had much more experience. I was a fan of Adam’s but he lost me with his “adult” performance during family prime time. Just not my cup of tea. Just because we have different opinions doesn’t mean we can’t still be music and American Idol fans – that’s the beauty of life – otherwise we’d only have one genre of music and very limited options. As it is … I still love watching James perform especially because he seems to love it so much and that enthusiasm certainly comes across to me.
April 25th, 2011 at 7:21 am
if that loser scream James Durbin is not voted off soon, if he will end up on 2nd place, i will never watch AI ever again. Sick and tired of screamers like James D, Adam L, they both suck big time.
April 27th, 2011 at 6:00 pm
I just watched James “singing” a slow melody…my foot, even when it is a slow song, he screams like a bison in heat, disgusting
April 27th, 2011 at 8:57 pm
I’m just interested in when you’ve actually heard bison in heat.
April 28th, 2011 at 6:04 pm
Casey is out but the screamer not. I am wondering if the results can be fixed?!?
http://blog.autismspeaks.org/2011/04/06/join-the-austim-speaks-james-durbin-voting-club-2/
May 11th, 2011 at 10:31 pm
And tonight my “favored” Tarzan boy launch loudly his trademark screams “impressing” me to tears, damn it, I have to support him another week?!? hopefully not
May 12th, 2011 at 6:17 pm
James. We will buy every one of your albums. You are an amazing artist!!! You have achieved tremendous success and will have a great career. We look forward to your concerts, albums and performances across the country. Outstanding!
From his daughter- OMG james ur AWSOME!!! ur my FAVORITE!!! uR my favorite idol EVER!!! i cant wait for ur albums to come out!!!
<3
May 13th, 2011 at 10:24 am
[edited for content] THE FINALIST SHOLD HAVE BEEN JAMES AND LAUREN AND TOP THREE JAMES LAUREN AND HAYLY BUT REALLY SCOTTY, AMERICA LISTEN MORE TO DA KIND OF MUSIC EVERYONE SANG OTHER THAN SCOTTY…DONT GET ME WRONG SCOTTY IS GOOD BUT THE OTHER THREE THEY WHRERE BETTER…IS USELESS TO WATCH IT ANYMORE…THE JUDGES ARE DUMB TO LET AMERICA VOTE HIM OFF….THE RULES NEED TO CHANGE BECAUSE AMERICA JUST PICKS BY WHO IS CUTER NOT WHO SINGS BETTER
May 13th, 2011 at 11:54 am
James, real talent? to do what? Maybe something else but not music. You can say talent if you r refering to Casey…how many instruments he plays?!? and good?!?
May 15th, 2011 at 8:54 am
James is real talent..I cant believe that anyone would give him such bad comments about his “screaming” as you all call it! James was by far the one contestant that was truely heart and soul invested into Idol this season. Noone can say that he ever got any bad comments from the judges or that one of his songs sang was less than 110%! James is what American Idol should be about! He will go far beyond Idol. James will always be great! [edited for content]
May 24th, 2011 at 6:31 pm
American Idol became boring after James left